Off Topic Section?

[Ree]

Thanks for the reminder.

[Boozy]

I have some concerns about an Off Topic section here at Fratching, and I thought I'd share them here and get some feedback from everyone.

As it stands now, every thread here is fair game for debate. Even if someone decides to post about their personal issues (in say, "Things I Hate"), there is an understanding that people may disagree with something they've said or how they've handled the issue.

Fratching is, after all, a debate forum.

If we add an Off Topic section, the question becomes, "Do the same rules apply here as in the rest of the forum?" If someone posts something in the Off Topic section, can they expect to receive only support and friendly suggestions, or are people allowed to debate with them?

Having separate rules for different sub-forums can become messy. And I don't want to see people posting about potentially controversial issues in the Off Topic section knowing that no one can argue with them.

On the other hand - allowing debate about a member's personal life can also get messy. We've seen that happen already.

Thoughts?

[telecom_goddess]

I say if they post something in an Off Topic section let others debate with them, that's the point of the board as a whole yes?

[Ree]

I would think every forum is open to debate.

I am wondering if, instead of "Off Topic" we give it a different name to indicate that it's a bit of a "catch-all" forum for topics that don't fit anywhere else.

After all, I really think that was the intent when the idea was suggested.

Originally Posted by Mytical

Sometimes I am not sure where to put something, because it does not seem to fit any of the other categories. I would like to suggest an Off topic section, that covers 'everything else'.

[Mytical]

Yes. In my opinion there would be no need for special rules, if something is posted in such a thread it would still be up for debate. As for what to call it *shrugs* 'Off topic', 'Everything else', 'Rants', or whatever .

[Ree]

Originally Posted by Mytical

As for what to call it *shrugs* 'Off topic',

I think the name is very important, and that's Boozy's point.
"Off Topic" gives an implication that it's a forum free from the subject of the rest of the board. There is a legitimate concern that some may think that means it's also a section that's free from debate.

[Mytical]

*nods* Would 'Everything Else' be any better?

[Boozy]

Originally Posted by Ree

I think the name is very important, and that's Boozy's point.
"Off Topic" gives an implication that it's a forum free from the subject of the rest of the board. There is a legitimate concern that some may think that means it's also a section that's free from debate.

Thanks for putting it more succinctly than I could, Ree.

If everyone is on board with the idea that an "off topic" section, whatever it is called, is still for debate, then I think we could move forward.

[telecom_goddess]

looks like it's in place now, interesting title for it btw.

[Mytical]

Yes . I love the name!