Originally posted by smileyeagle1021
View Post
I find it baffling that people don't seem to grasp that concept. But if it's beyond you, then look at it this way - We are better than them. You don't need to lower yourself down to their level just to punish them.
It's not a flaw. It's a feature. It's there for a reason, and that reason is that a government has more power than individuals. Anyone living in a dictatorship can be imprisoned because of the power imbalance between the government and the individual. Nearly every Western democracy broke it's monarchist/dictatorship shackles and replaced the legal system with one where if the state wishes to imprison you, then they need to prove you deserve it beyond reasonable doubt, not to a judge, or a bureaucrat, but to normal citizens. Your peers. That's quite telling in and of itself.
I've personally witnessed a case where a man who was proven guilty of raping and torturing a 16 year old girl was appealing his sentence of solitary confinement because it was such a cruel punishment... bullshit, a cruel, yet just, punishment would be cutting off his dick to make sure he never does it again, compared to his actions solitary confinement is a mercy... the courts agreed with him and moved him to general population.
At the other end of the spectrum, even petty criminals are given more rights than their victims. One of my grandma's friends owned property, squatters moved into it, when my grandma's friend tried to have them arrested for trespassing, they were informed that the squatters were in fact not trespassing, they did have rights, they would have to go through an eviction process, and by the way, her friend was fined for not maintaining the property to state standards for rental housing. That's right, the courts punished her friend, the VICTIM of the crime and rewarded the criminals. Ask me again how much respect I have for our legal system.
Comment